Q: Can I finish a wooden plank floor I’ve discovered in a bedroom in my cottage when we removed old flooring? The bedroom is over a half-height crawl space where the pump and electrical panel is. My brother-in-law says we need to put a finished floor on top of this plank floor because it’s the only layer present. Bugs and dampness will come up, he says. I’d really like to finish this beautiful floor and live with it. Am I wrong?
A: I agree with your suggestion. Since this is a summer place only, there’s certainly no problem finishing the planks and living with them. You can even leave them bare, as you see above. The issue of bugs and dampness probably won’t be a problem, but if it is, installing lengths of plywood underneath the planks, between the joists, is one good way to deal with it while maintaining the look you’ve got. It’s a lot less work and expense than putting a new floor on top of what you’ve got, and it preserves the simple look of a good cottage.
What sort of finish did you have in mind for the floor if you were going to put one on? A wooden floor in an informal place, as you’ve described, doesn’t even need finishing. I’ve seen bare-wood plank floors in action and they work quite well for decades. In fact, unfinished wood floors were the norm for centuries in simple buildings. The only reason for finishing would be to make the floor look more formal. Several coats of urethane would make the floor a bit easier to sweep, but in the olden days, many houses had bare wood floors that were swept and washed and took on an attractive, worn look in time. Besides, isn’t part of the attraction of a cottage that you can come inside without taking your shoes off, with no concerns about scratching the floor?
Cottages tend to become sink holes for massive amounts of labour because of how they’re built and finished. There are definitely some labour-saving strategies you can apply to any cottage, and this goes beyond flooring choice. Click on the image below for a detailed article on the “easy-keeper” cottage.